Skip to content

Pa. could suspend IBX, Highmark, Jefferson contract terminations for up to six months, but can’t force a deal

The regulatory action would prevent disruption at the end of this year for thousands of Pennsylvania residents, but it would not ensure that Jefferson and the insurers secure new agreements.

The Pennsylvania Insurance Department last week detailed its plans to intervene in the contentious contract negotiations between Highmark, Independence Blue Cross, and Jefferson Health to ensure patients continue receiving care if the parties don’t have new agreements by Dec. 31.

The first step would be to suspend the contract terminations for up to six months and then schedule public hearings to investigate the reasons for the terminations, the department said in letters sent Friday to the CEOs of Highmark, Independence, and Jefferson.

The department, however, cannot force the insurers and the Philadelphia region’s largest health system to reach a deal under Act 94 of 1975, which gives regulators the right to take the planned steps. Jefferson also owns Lehigh Valley Health Network, which stretches from Allentown north. That’s an area where Highmark has a large share of the insurance market.

The department is regularly hearing from Pennsylvania residents worried about continued access to their doctors next year, the letters said.

“The fear of not being able to continue to see an existing provider, or wondering how to find a new location for one’s next scan or preventive service will take place, is very real,” insurance commissioner Michael Humphreys said in the letters, which the department provided to The Inquirer.

The letters ask for lists of the Jefferson locations that accept Highmark and Independence insurance, information on how the parties are handling appointments and preauthorization for next year, and contract negotiation updates every week starting Nov. 25.

It’s not unusual for contract talks to go down to the wire, but the negotiations between Jefferson and Highmark and Independence Blue Cross have been more public than most. Both Jefferson and Independence have advertised their positions to sway public opinion.

Highmark and Independence said they continue negotiating.

“We remain focused on our members and on negotiating an agreement with Jefferson Health that preserves access to quality care at an affordable cost. Consistent with the Commonwealth’s focus under Act 94 on consumer protection and continuity of care, we will continue working toward a resolution that shields our members and customers from unsustainable cost increases,” Independence said in an email.

Highmark provided a similar statement: “We remain focused on reaching a fair agreement with Jefferson Health. Our priority is to ensure access to quality, affordable care for the people we serve.”

Jefferson, which is also negotiating a new contract with Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey, said in its statement to The Inquirer:

“We welcome the commissioner’s engagement and support a transparent, independent analysis of the issues at the center of these negotiations. We’re hopeful in finding a sustainable approach that protects patients’ access to the physicians, hospitals and specialized services they depend on.”