Skip to content

Inis Nua, People's Light, and Wilma Theater win big at the 2026 Barrymore Awards

“Tonight is the night for recognizing ourselves, celebrating ourselves and each other,” said host R. Eric Thomas. “It is not about creating a hierarchy. It is about saying that we are a community."

Pax Ressler (left) and Jackie Soro perform “When I Was A Kid”, from GIRL DOLLS: The American Musical during the 2026 Barrymore Awards at the Suzanne Roberts Theatre on Monday, Nov. 16, 2026.
Pax Ressler (left) and Jackie Soro perform “When I Was A Kid”, from GIRL DOLLS: The American Musical during the 2026 Barrymore Awards at the Suzanne Roberts Theatre on Monday, Nov. 16, 2026.Read moreYong Kim / Staff Photographer

It was a festive night full of laughs, songs, cheers, happy tears, and tequila shots at the Suzanne Roberts Theatre as Theatre Philadelphia hosted its 2026 Barrymore Awards ceremony on Monday.

The celebratory crowd packed the house as the magnetic host, playwright and actor R. Eric Thomas, kept the jokes coming — opening the show with a cheeky original song “No Funny Business” and tossing props from nominated shows into the audience, like a soccer ball, lays, and packs of cigarettes (“Who wants to smoke cigarettes with Martin Luther King?” he asked, referencing The Mountaintop.)

“Tonight is the night for recognizing ourselves, celebrating ourselves and each other,” said Thomas. “It is not about creating a hierarchy. It is about saying that we are a community. So I want you to turn to your neighbor and say, ‘You did that s—.’”

Over the course of the evening, Theatre Philadelphia highlighted dozens of productions staged by 18 regional theater companies, from Center City’s Inis Nua Theatre Company to Malvern’s People’s Light Theatre Company to Delaware Shakespeare in Wilmington.

Award presenters included Philadelphia notables City Councilmember Rue Landau, PHL17’s Positively Philly hosts Abby Urban and Rachel Malak, and Pulitzer Prize-winning playwright James Ijames.

People’s Light’s production of Little Shop of Horrors, which was nominated for 11 Barrymores, took home the award for outstanding overall production of a musical. The production also won for the inaugural Barrymore for outstanding props or puppetry design — recognizing scenic and puppet designer Anton Volovsek and costume and puppet designer Camilla Dely — and outstanding leading performance in a musical, for Anna Faye Lieberman (who played the kind and clumsy shop assistant Seymour).

Outstanding overall production of a play went to the Wilma Theater’s staging of The Most Spectacularly Lamentable Trial of Miz Martha Washington, a 2014 historical comedy from erstwhile South Philadelphian playwright Ijames (a former coartistic director at the Wilma). Ijames himself announced the award and longtime Wilma stage manager Patreshettarlini Adams accepted. Nikki Delhomme also won the Barrymore for outstanding costume design.

The hilariously subversive play, which imagines the first lady on her deathbed, hallucinating that the enslaved people around her are plotting her murder, arrived in Philadelphia amid the Trump administration’s efforts to whitewash the history of George and Martha Washington’s participation in slavery at the President’s House on Independence Mall earlier this year.

Two theater companies went home with the highest number of wins, both receiving five Barrymore Awards each: Inis Nua, which stages works from the U.K. and Ireland at the Drake, and Arden Theatre Company, based in Old City.

Inis Nua won for its productions Same Team, Can’t Forget About You, and The Greatest Play in the History of the World (a coproduction with Tiny Dynamite). A heartwarming story about a ragtag women’s soccer team in Scotland, Same Team won outstanding ensemble in a play and actor Page Whitman won the Barrymore for outstanding leading performance in a play.

The Irish rom-com Can’t Forget About You picked up two awards, including outstanding direction of a play for Kathryn MacMillan and outstanding choreography/movement in a play for K. O’Rourke. Lighting designer Shannon Zura won the Barrymore for her work on The Greatest Play in the History of the World; she had also been nominated for Good Bones.

Arden Theatre’s actors received several awards across three productions. Both awards for outstanding supporting performance in a musical went to Falsettos actors Katherine Fried and Will Stephan Connell. They played Trina and Whizzer, respectively, in the complicated family story set during the AIDS epidemic. Behind the curtain, Gina Giachero won for outstanding music direction of a musical.

For the Arden’s production of James Ijames’ gentrification play Good Bones, South Philly-raised actor Walter DeShields won an award for outstanding supporting performance in a play, recognizing his compelling role as Earl, a contractor who’s passionate about his changing neighborhood and doesn’t want to see it demolished for the sake of a new sports stadium.

In addition to Good Bones and Falsettos, the Arden’s production of Katori Hall’s The Mountaintop — which follows Martin Luther King on the night before his assassination in 1968 — also landed in the spotlight. Actor Kishia Nixon won outstanding leading performance in a play for her role as Camae, a fictional maid who mysteriously appears in his motel room with an important message.

The other major acting awards went to Felicity Mundy, who won outstanding leading performance in a musical for playing Wendla Bergmann in the newly founded Relic Theatre Company’s inaugural production Spring Awakening, and David Ingram, who received the award for outstanding supporting performance in a play for tackling several roles in Philadelphia Theatre Company’s staging of Primary Trust. (Spring Awakening also won for outstanding ensemble for a musical.)

Curio Theatre Company’s world premiere of Sacco & Vanzetti: A Tragedia dell’Arte received the Philadelphia Award for Social Insight, which spotlights a production that examined the complexity of our society and “shed light on customs, cultures, histories, and traditions that are too frequently overlooked.” The award comes with a cash prize of $25,000 for the West Philly-based theater. From Philadelphia actor/director John Bellomo, Sacco & Vanzetti was based on the true story of two Italian immigrants wrongfully convicted of murder in Massachusetts in 1921, who were eventually executed — an injustice fueled by anti-immigrant bias.

Three finalists for the Social Insight Award each received a cash prize of $2,500: New Light Theatre’s The White Chip, Azuka Theatre and Simpatico Theatre’s 1 Pound 4 Ounces, and Theatre Exile’s The Great Privation.

See the full list of winners (in bold) and nominees here:

Outstanding overall production of a play

  1. The Most Spectacularly Lamentable Trial of Miz Martha Washington — The Wilma Theater, stage managed by Patreshettarlini Adams

  2. Same Team — Inis Nua Theatre Company, staged managed by Celia HuttonJohns

  3. La Otra — 1812 Productions, stage managed by Alexis Wells

  4. Walden — InterAct Theatre Company, stage managed by Abby Sturgis

  5. The Garbologists — Montgomery Theatre, stage managed by Brian Goldblatt

  6. Primary Trust — Philadelphia Theatre Company, stage managed by Jamel Baker

  7. The Mountaintop — Arden Theatre Company, stage managed by Matthew Ryan Melchior

Outstanding overall production of a musical

  1. Little Shop of Horrors — People’s Light, stage managed by Jess McPhillips

  2. GIRL DOLLS: The American Musical — Bearded Ladies Cabaret, stage managed by CD Kincade

  3. Wishing To Grow Up Brightly — Theatre Horizon, stage managed by Alec E. Ferrell

  4. Spring Awakening — Relic Theatre Company, stage managed by Asher Vaglica

  5. Falsettos — Arden Theatre Company, stage managed by Tom Shotkin

Outstanding direction of a play

  1. Kittson O’Neill — Same Team, Inis Nua Theatre Company

  2. Kimille Howard — Plantation Black, InterAct Theatre Company

  3. Brett Ashley Robinson — The Most Spectacularly Lamentable Trial of Miz Martha Washington, The Wilma Theater

  4. Tanaquil Márquez — La Otra, 1812 Productions

  5. Amina Robinson — Primary Trust, Philadelphia Theatre Company

  6. Rebecca Wright — Class C, Azuka Theatre and Simpatico Theatre

  7. Kathryn MacMillan — Can’t Forget About You, Inis Nua Theatre Company

Outstanding ensemble in a play

  1. The Most Spectacularly Lamentable Trial of Miz Martha Washington — The Wilma Theater

  2. FIRE!! — Quintessence Theatre

  3. Plantation Black — InterAct Theatre Company

  4. Little Women — Hedgerow Theatre Company

  5. Same Team — Inis Nua Theatre Company

  6. La Otra — 1812 Productions

  7. The Woman Question — People’s Light

Outstanding leading performance in a play

  1. Ebony Pullum — Blues for an Alabama Sky, Lantern Theater Company

  2. Adam Howard — Why I Stuck a Flare Up My Arse for England, Inis Nua Theatre Company

  3. Noelle Diane Johnson — The Garbologists, Montgomery Theater

  4. David Pica — Class C, Azuka Theatre and Simpatico Theatre

  5. Leo Mock — Little Women, Hedgerow Theatre Company

  6. Travoye Joyner — Romeo and Juliet, Arden Theatre Company

  7. Kishia Nixon —The Mountaintop, Arden Theatre Company

  8. Newton Buchanan — Primary Trust, Philadelphia Theatre Company

  9. V. Sterling — Same Team, Inis Nua Theatre Company

  10. Phillip Brown — Dutchman and the Slave, Passage Theatre Company

  11. Page Whitman — Same Team, Inis Nua Theatre Company

  12. Brett Ashley Robinson — The Greatest Play in the History of the World, Inis Nua Theatre Company and Tiny Dynamite

  13. Matthew Pfeiffer — The Garbologists, Montgomery Theater

  14. Olive Gallagher — Little Women, Hedgerow Theatre Company

Outstanding supporting performance in a play

  1. Megan Bellwoar — Can’t Forget About You, Inis Nua Theatre Company

  2. Jared Delaney — Romeo and Juliet, Arden Theatre Company

  3. Minou Pourshariati — Little Women, Hedgerow Theatre Company

  4. David Ingram — Primary Trust, Philadelphia Theatre Company

  5. Taylor J. Mitchell — Blues for an Alabama Sky, Lantern Theater Company

  6. Jered McLenigan — The Hypochondriac, Quintessence Theatre

  7. Unissa Cruse — Muleheaded, or Zora and Langston Write a Play, Passage Theatre Company

  8. Frank Jimenez — Romeo and Juliet, Arden Theatre Company

  9. David M. Raine — La Otra, 1812 Productions

  10. Daniel Burgess — A Wrinkle in Time, Arden Theatre Company

  11. Walter DeShields — Good Bones, Arden Theatre Company

  12. Dave Johnson — Spinner, Delaware Theatre Company

  13. Brandon J. Pierce — The America Play, The Wilma Theater

Outstanding choreography/movement in a play

  1. Kittson O’Neill and Lane LaVonne — Same Team, Inis Nua Theatre Company

  2. Polanco Jones Jr., Quinton J. Alexander, and Bess Rowen — FIRE!!, Quintessence Theatre

  3. K. O’Rourke — Can’t Forget About You, Inis Nua Theatre Company

  4. Dominic Moore-Dunson — The Most Spectacularly Lamentable Trial of Miz Martha Washington, The Wilma Theater

  5. Fatima Sowe — The Woman Question, People’s Light

  6. MK Tuomanen — The Presented, Chris Davis

  7. Ryk Lewis — Coloring Book, Fusion Performing Arts Center

Outstanding lighting design

  1. Shannon Zura — The Greatest Play in the History of the World, Inis Nua Theatre Company and Tiny Dynamite

  2. Lindsay Stevens — Walden, InterAct Theatre Company

  3. Shannon Zura — Good Bones, Arden Theatre Company

  4. Maria Shaplin — The Most Spectacularly Lamentable Trial of Miz Martha Washington, The Wilma Theater

  5. Christopher Ash — Caesar, Philadelphia Theatre Company

  6. Lily Fossner — The Garbologists, Montgomery Theater

  7. Cat Tate Starmer — The Unexpected 3rd: A Radical, Rollicking Rumination on the Optimism of Staying Alive, People’s Light

Outstanding scenic design

  1. Chris Haig — Walden, InterAct Theatre Company

  2. Colin McIlvane — The Most Spectacularly Lamentable Trial of Miz Martha Washington, The Wilma Theater

  3. Meghan Jones — The Garbologists, Montgomery Theater

  4. Reiko Huffman —The Mountaintop, Arden Theatre Company

  5. Nick Embree — Can’t Forget About You, Inis Nua Theatre Company

  6. Nina Ball — The Unexpected 3rd: A Radical, Rollicking Rumination on the Optimism of Staying Alive, People’s Light

  7. Andrew Robinson — Gemini, EgoPo Classic Theater

Outstanding costume design

  1. Nikki Delhomme — The Most Spectacularly Lamentable Trial of Miz Martha Washington, The Wilma Theater

  2. Rebecca Kanach — Twelfth Night, People’s Light

  3. Tiffany Bacon — Muleheaded, or Zora and Langston Write a Play, Passage Theatre Company

  4. Ivania Stack and Bailey Hammett-Colwell — The Snow Queen, The Wilma Theater

  5. Camilla Dely — Little Shop of Horrors, People’s Light

  6. Nikki Delhomme — A Wrinkle in Time, Arden Theatre Company

  7. Tracy Christensen — Steel Magnolias, People’s Light

Outstanding sound design

  1. Larry Fowler — The America Play, The Wilma Theater

  2. Jordan McCree — The Most Spectacularly Lamentable Trial of Miz Martha Washington, The Wilma Theater

  3. Natali Merrill — Walden, InterAct Theatre Company

  4. Carsen Joenk — Steel Magnolias, People’s Light

  5. Andrew Nelson — JOB, Theatre Exile

  6. Jordan McCree — Caesar, Philadelphia Theatre Company

  7. Mel Hsu — A Wrinkle in Time, Arden Theatre Company

Outstanding media design

  1. Jorge Cousineau —The Mountaintop, Arden Theatre Company

  2. Taj Rauch — Wilderness Generation, Philadelphia Theatre Company

  3. Taj Rauch and Nia Benjamin — Girl Dolls: The American Musical, Bearded Ladies Cabaret

  4. Michael Long — La Otra, 1812 Productions

  5. Christopher Ash — Caesar, Philadelphia Theatre Company

Outstanding original music

  1. Jackie Soro and Pax Ressler — Girl Dolls: The American Musical, Bearded Ladies Cabaret

  2. Amanda Morton and Josh Totora — Wishing to Grow Up Brightly, Theatre Horizon

  3. Jordan McCree — The Most Spectacularly Lamentable Trial of Miz Martha Washington, The Wilma Theater

  4. Liz Filios — Twelfth Night, People’s Light

  5. Selena Seballo and Jack Denman — The Chequerboard Watch: A New Musical, Delaware Theatre Company

  6. Adam Faulk — FIRE!!, Quintessence Theatre

Outstanding props or puppetry design

  1. Anton Volovsek and Camilla Dely — Little Shop of Horrors, People’s Light

  2. Paul Kuhn and Ren Bailey — Sacco & Vanzetti: A Tragedia dell’Arte, Curio Theatre Company

  3. Clare Wislar — Marsha Blovotnick and the Marvelous Magical Chicken Soup, Theatre Ariel

  4. Kelly McLaughlan — The Stinky Cheese Man and Other Fairly Stupid Tales, Arden Theatre Company

  5. Jen Burkhart — Wishing to Grow Up Brightly, Theatre Horizon

  6. Ryan Canney — The Garbologists, Montgomery Theatre

  7. Colleen Murray — Lions, Lightning Rod Special

Outstanding direction of a musical

  1. Robi Hager — Spring Awakening, Relic Theatre Company

  2. MK Tuomanen — Girl Dolls: The American Musical, Bearded Ladies Cabaret

  3. Amina Robinson — Ain’t Misbehavin’, Theatre Horizon

  4. Molly Rosa Hulahan — Little Shop of Horrors, People’s Light

Outstanding ensemble in a musical

  1. Falsettos — Arden Theatre Company

  2. Little Shop of Horrors — People’s Light

  3. Spring Awakening — Relic Theatre Company

  4. Jelly’s Last Jam — Bristol Riverside Theatre

  5. Ain’t Misbehavin’ — Theatre Horizon

Outstanding leading performance in a musical

  1. Anna Faye Lieberman — Little Shop of Horrors, People’s Light

  2. Jessica Money — Little Shop of Horrors, People’s Light

  3. Felicity Mundy — Spring Awakening, Relic Theatre Company

  4. Evan Kaushesh — Dear Evan Hansen, Arden Theatre Company

  5. Steve Pacek — Falsettos, Arden Theatre Company

  6. Stanley Martin — Jelly’s Last Jam, Bristol Riverside Theatre

  7. Francesca Marchese — Fun Home, Media Theatre

  8. Sami Ma — Wishing to Grow Up Brightly, Theatre Horizon

Outstanding supporting performance in a musical

  1. Alison Ansorg — Fun Home, Media Theatre

  2. Katie Boren — Wishing to Grow Up Brightly, Theatre Horizon

  3. Katherine Fried — Falsettos, Arden Theatre Company

  4. Will Stephan Connell — Falsettos, Arden Theatre Company

  5. Mary Elizabeth Scallen — Little Shop of Horrors, People’s Light

  6. Andrew Kane — Little Shop of Horrors, People’s Light

  7. Dana Orange — Jelly’s Last Jam, Bristol Riverside Theatre

  8. Charlie Barney — Annie, Media Theatre

Outstanding choreography/movement in a musical

  1. Julianna Babb, Noelle Diane Johnson, and J. Oliver Donahue — Spring Awakening, Relic Theatre Company

  2. Melanie Cotton and Eli Lynn — Little Shop of Horrors, People’s Light

  3. yaTande Whitney V. Hunter and DeWitt Fleming Jr. — Jelly’s Last Jam, Bristol Riverside Theatre

  4. Eliana Pinckney — Ain’t Misbehavin’, Theatre Horizon

Outstanding music direction of a musical

  1. Pax Ressler — Girl Dolls, Bearded Ladies Cabaret

  2. Brigitte Rottman — Little Shop of Horrors, People’s Light

  3. Brigitte Rottman — Wishing to Grow Up Brightly, Theatre Horizon

  4. Gina Giachero — Falsettos, Arden Theatre Company

Outstanding outdoor production

  1. A Bottom’s Dream — Shakespeare in Clark Park

  2. Twelfth Night, O Lo Que Quieras — Delaware Shakespeare

  3. Fraternity — Theatre in the X

Outstanding original production

  1. Jackie Soro and Pax Ressler — Girl Dolls: The American Musical, Bearded Ladies

  2. Chaz T. Martin — Class C, Azuka Theatre and Simpatico Theatre

  3. Alice Yorke and Scott R. Sheppard — Lions, Lightning Rod Special

  4. John Bellomo — Sacco & Vanzetti: A Tragedia dell’Arte, Curio Theatre Company

  5. Chris Davis — The Presented, Chris Davis

  6. Dan Kitrosser — Marsha Blovotnik and the Magical Chicken Soup, Theatre Ariel

  7. Saymoukda Duangphouxay Vongsay — Seng’s Hair Salon, InterAct Theatre Company

The Philadelphia award for social insight

  1. Inheritors — Philadelphia Artists’ Collective

  2. Draw the Circle — Hedgerow Theatre Company

  3. Good Bones — Arden Theatre Company

  4. The White Chip — New Light Theatre

  5. Sacco & Vanzetti: A Tragedia dell’Arte — Curio Theatre Company

  6. Ain’t Misbehavin’ — Theatre Horizon

  7. The Woman Question — People’s Light

  8. The America Play — Wilma Theater

  9. Franklinland — Lantern Theater Company

  10. Same Team — Inis Nua Theatre Company

  11. The Great Privation — Theatre Exile

  12. 1 Pound 4 Ounces — Azuka Theatre and Simpatico Theatre