Skip to content

With the midterms behind them, lawmakers must now confront the cost of destroying nature

With a new balance of power in Washington, legislators have an opportunity to reconsider policies that subsidize environmental destruction, threatening the natural systems that sustain our economy.

Neighbors embrace outside a damaged home Mullica Hill, N.J. in September 2021. Widespread flooding and tornadoes from Hurricane Ida did $1.8 billion in damage to the Philadelphia area.

Tatiana Der Avedissian is a communications and sustainability expert. She is the founder of Mereweg, England’s first blue economy cluster and a member of Leading Women for the Ocean.

The midterm elections in the United States have changed the balance of power in Washington. And among the most pressing issues facing the new Congress, one deserves far more attention than it usually receives: Why do the world’s governments help pay for the destruction of the natural systems that sustain us?

All over the world, governments are subsidizing policies that harm our forests, fisheries, and other resources at a rate that dwarfs the spending to protect them, according to the World Bank. This is far from just an environmental catastrophe; it is an economic calamity. Old policies that are no longer tenable are still being maintained despite the fact they no longer make economic sense.

Why care?

Why should ordinary people care about biodiversity? After all, most of us have enough to worry about without counting species, and in the United States today even the word “diversity” is contentious. But you don’t have to love nature to depend on it.

Pennsylvania offers a prime example. In Philadelphia, where the Schuylkill and Delaware rivers shape the city’s geography, flooding is already an expensive reality. The city estimates that damage from a single major storm in 2021 exceeded $1.3 billion. Healthy wetlands, forests, and floodplains help absorb rainfall and reduce the damage such events can cause. Protecting these natural defenses is an economic investment that can save taxpayers billions.

When forests and wetlands are damaged, communities lose protection from floods and access to reliable sources of clean water. When bees and other pollinators disappear, crops suffer. When fisheries decline, families lose food and jobs. The costs show up in grocery bills, water supplies, and livelihoods. The Trump administration has shown little enthusiasm for international environmental cooperation, but this is a problem that deserves attention across party lines.

That is why the recent United Nations biodiversity conference, COP17, which took place last month in Yerevan, Armenia, matters well beyond the circle of environmental experts who participated in it. Governments have already promised to protect more of the planet’s land and waters and repair damaged ecosystems, but will they actually do it and pay for it? The answer will affect families and businesses far from the conference halls.

Studies have shown that funding and protection efforts are falling short of governments’ own promises. The World Bank estimates the cost of failing to aggressively protect the environment at $2.7 trillion by 2030. This is about food, health, work, and the security of our communities.

The Trump administration has made weakening environmental protections a central element of its economic agenda.

The scale of this self-inflicted damage is staggering. According to a United Nations Environment Programme report released in January, governments worldwide provided $2.4 trillion in environmentally harmful subsidies in 2023 dealing with fossil fuels, agriculture, water, transport, and construction. Such economic incentives encourage excessive resource consumption, over-intensive farming, and the destruction of habitats. Meanwhile, the world invested just $220 billion in nature-based solutions in 2023. Including private sector financing, money flowing into the activities that damage nature outweighed the investment in protecting it by roughly 30 to 1.

Destructive policies

The United States offers a particularly troubling example. The Trump administration has made weakening environmental protections a central element of its economic agenda. In July, it narrowed protections under the Endangered Species Act, making it easier for logging, mining, and drilling operations to proceed in wildlife habitats. The administration presents such measures as removing obstacles to growth, yet forests, wetlands, and functioning ecosystems are productive economic assets, supplying clean water, protecting communities, and sustaining agriculture. Policies that encourage their destruction transfer costs from businesses to taxpayers, families, and future generations.

The U.S. should be leading the effort to counter these incentives. Instead, its government is moving in the opposite direction. Paradoxically, the administration last week unveiled the new America First Seafood Strategy to try to protect the American fisheries industry, which demonstrates that officials understand the economic imperative of protecting livelihoods.

War makes the danger to our environment even more immediate. Research on the Persian Gulf shows that attacks, oil spills, and chemical contamination can damage coral reefs, mangroves, and other marine habitats, with consequences for aquaculture and the water supplies of countries that depend on desalination. Pollution does not stop at a border. Protecting shared ecosystems requires cooperation even among governments that disagree on almost everything else.

Focus on oceans

The oceans offer a particularly urgent test of whether governments intend to turn promises into reality. Much of the world’s biodiversity work has focused on land, but our oceans demand equal attention. Three priorities stand out: integrating the new High Seas Treaty into global biodiversity efforts, protecting 30% of the planet’s land and seas by 2030, and ensuring that marine protected areas are more than “paper parks,” where destructive practices such as bottom trawling, a destructive method that affects our sea floor to catch fish and other marine species living close to the seabed, can still take place.

We also need better marine spatial planning, too. Governments must balance offshore wind farms, aquaculture, undersea cables, and shipping routes with genuine conservation, rather than allowing one activity to undermine another. And Indigenous peoples and coastal communities must have a meaningful voice in these decisions, not merely be consulted after the fact. Their livelihoods and futures are directly at stake.

Governments must stop subsidizing the destruction of the natural systems on which their economies depend. This cannot be left to environmental policy makers alone. It requires a collective governmental effort including leaders in agriculture, finance, trade, and infrastructure to recognize that maintaining healthy ecosystems are just as vital to long-term prosperity as roads or power grids.

COP17 concluded with the adoption of the Yerevan Pathway, a roadmap for accelerating global biodiversity protection through 2030. The conference also announced nearly $2 billion in new biodiversity financing and strengthened conservation commitments, although significant challenges remain in meeting global targets.

What to do

All of that is useful, but governments need to make practical commitments: Stop rewarding environmental destruction and commit significant funding toward biodiversity. The commitment secured so far, $1.8 billion, does not come close to the amount needed, which is $700 billion annually to fully protect global ecosystems. To achieve this, international cooperation is needed because nature crosses borders, whether politicians like it or not.

Individual citizens have a role, too. We can press elected officials to treat healthy land and water as essential rather than a luxury or afterthought. We can reconsider the brands we buy, support organizations doing serious, science-based restoration work, and demand greater accountability for how public money is spent.

You do not have to be an environmentalist, or belong to any particular political party, to insist that governments stop paying to destroy what keeps us alive.

The midterms have created a new political reality in Washington, but they have not changed the economic realities confronting America and the world. Whether Democrats and Republicans can agree on environmental policy is another matter. Yet protecting fisheries, securing water supplies, preserving productive farmland, and preventing costly natural disasters should not be understood as exclusively partisan objectives. They are fundamental economic interests.

The incoming Congress has an opportunity to scrutinize subsidies that reward environmental destruction, examine the long-term costs of weakened protections, and demand that public spending reflect the true economic value of healthy ecosystems. The Trump administration, meanwhile, has an opportunity to demonstrate that its commitment to American prosperity includes protecting the natural assets on which that prosperity depends.

You do not have to be an environmentalist, or belong to any particular political party, to insist that governments stop paying to destroy what keeps us alive. After the midterms, that is a question both parties should be prepared to address.

About guest essays

Guest essays, or op-eds, are commentary pieces that present the opinion or perspective of the author. Many are submitted to us by Inquirer readers and writers with insight on the news, but we also solicit op-eds from authors on specific topics. For more information visit our guidelines.