Congress is on the verge of upending landmark environmental laws. Here’s how.
The measure could pass the Senate as soon as this week and then would head to the House. Here’s what it would actually do for clean energy, data centers and fossil fuels.
For weeks, Democrats and environmental groups have been torn apart by a bill making its way through Congress. The measure, known as the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA), would ease the way for the development of vast wind and solar farms, and ensure data centers pay their fair share for electricity — but it also would spur fossil fuel development and, according to some lawyers, eviscerate existing environmental laws.
Experts say that however you view the bill, it will fundamentally transform America’s environmental laws. “No one alive has experienced a proposal of this magnitude for the environment,” said Danny Cullenward, an economist and lawyer at the University of Pennsylvania’s Kleinman Center for Energy Policy.
The measure could pass the Senate as soon as this week and then would head to the House. Here’s what it would actually do for clean energy, data centers and fossil fuels.
Data centers
Data centers would have strict requirements on financing their own power if the bill passes. The public roundly dismissed data centers during the midterm elections, with voters opting to restrict or slow such development in 40 of 41 local ballot races around the country. The only exception was North Dakota, where an 845-person town called Harwood voted against increasing data center oversight.
Currently, data centers have to pay for either their general cost of operating on the existing power grid, or the cost of any additional upgrades and transmission lines needed to serve them. That “either/or” policy means some of those costs could be passed on to consumers — although so far, the impacts seem to be small.
If the bill passes, data centers will have to pay for both — ensuring that those extra costs aren’t passed on to the consumer.
“The bill takes a pretty hard line on data centers,” Daniel Palken, director of infrastructure for energy and permitting at Arnold Ventures, a philanthropy that supports the bill, said in a briefing last week. “It’s virtually starting to err on the side of having data centers pay strictly more than their costs.”
Clean energy
Two of the Senate’s most dedicated climate hawks — Sheldon Whitehouse (D, R.I.) and Martin Heinrich (D, N.M.) — sponsored the bill, in large part because of how it would improve the large power lines that can carry solar and wind power across long distances.
“In many parts of the country, clean energy tends to be the cheapest and fastest-to-deploy energy,” said Ben Schifman, a senior technology fellow at the Institute for Progress and a former environmental lawyer. “But it has a real problem, and the problem is that it can’t get from where it’s needed to where the population centers are.”
The United States currently builds around 500 miles of high-voltage transmission lines every year — a tiny fraction of the roughly 5,000 miles the country needs to add per year to support the build-out of the grid. One infamous power line, the SunZia line from New Mexico to Arizona, took 17 years to gain final permitting approvals. Currently, states can block or indefinitely delay lines that they don’t think would provide local benefits, slowing the pace of building.
The bill would require utilities to upgrade existing transmission lines and give the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission a stronger role in planning and executing new high-power lines. Experts estimate that it would cut the time for new transmission lines to be approved from more than 10 years right now to around five or six years.
“In the status quo it’s very easy, comparatively speaking, to build fossil fuel infrastructure, fossil fuel pipelines — but very difficult to permit and build transmission lines,” Schifman said. The bill, he says, helps fix this problem, unlocking more wind and solar development. “If clean energy were on an even playing field, it would be winning,” he added.
Chad Whiteman, vice president of environment and regulatory affairs at the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, says that the bill would help lower prices by allowing a greater build-out of all types of energy, including renewables. “If we want to address climate, if we want address it in the time frame that scientists say we have to, then you have to be able to build those clean energy resources,” he said.
Fossil fuels
For some environmental groups, the problem with the bill is that even if it would unlock clean-energy development, it also could unleash more coal, oil, and gas development. The bill takes aim at the National Environmental Policy Act, a decades-old law that requires agencies to evaluate the environmental impact of a project that is on federal land, has a federal permit, or has federal funding. Currently, this review process takes almost four years, on average, and NEPA violations can result in a project’s approval being paused indefinitely or even revoked by the courts.
The new legislation says that a court can send the environmental review back to be revised but that during that revision, the project can still go forward. Critics say this amounts to repealing the law altogether.
“Does NEPA need to be reformed? You bet it does,” said David Bookbinder, a longtime environmental lawyer. “This isn’t that. This is simply repealing it.”
Abigail Dillen, president of the environmental law firm Earthjustice, says the bill would dramatically undercut environmental groups’ ability to fight polluting projects. “Our system is still built for oil and gas,” she said. Earthjustice opposes the bill.
Supporters say that the bill helps to fix a broken system, in which projects can be stalled for years or even decades. “Our permitting process is really, really bad,” Xan Fishman, executive vice president of the energy program at the Bipartisan Policy Center, said in a briefing. “It started with really good intentions, but it’s morphed into this process that takes years and years and years to get a yes or a no.”
Some research suggests the bill would give a slight edge to clean energy, although a small one. According to the research company Rhodium Group, the bill would spur development of both fossil fuels and clean energy, lowering greenhouse gas emissions by around 3% by 2040. But depending on how the next decade and a half goes, Rhodium also noted that it may not reduce emissions at all compared with the status quo.
Endangered species
Some other provisions of the bill also have been controversial. The bill would require that the “best available science” be used for the Endangered Species Act, which critics say could allow courts to leave out some emerging research when evaluating a species. It also would allow states to conduct endangered-species reviews, instead of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service — states that may not have the ability or desire to carry out those reviews.
“Any state that does not take the issue of endangered species seriously, the ESA is a dead letter,” Bookbinder said.
The bill also includes language around “project certainty,” a provision intended to help developers avoid a future president torpedoing projects that they don’t like. (For example, President Donald Trump has targeted wind farms, and both Presidents Barack Obama and Joe Biden halted the Keystone XL pipeline at different points.) The bill prevents the federal government from interfering with projects that already have all their applicable permits.
Some lawyers and environmentalists worry that it will make it harder for groups to fight projects that were given permits illegally: A president could issue permits during his or her term that would then be impossible to revoke. “You can imagine — maybe there’s a next ballroom to build,” Dillen said, referring to Trump’s White House project.
But others say that this provision has been fixed by language added during the amendment process, including to say that “certainty” affects only projects that obtained their permits legally.
“I am beyond satisfied that this is not going to produce the parade of horribles that people think it would,” Schifman said.
























