Skip to content

Former Penn State student accused of running fraternity cocaine ring faces federal charges

Agostino Abbatiello is accused of being a "major supplier" of cocaine at Penn State, operating out of two fraternities.

Agostino Abbatiello arrived to an appearance at Centre County Courthouse in Bellefonte, Pa. in early September.
Agostino Abbatiello arrived to an appearance at Centre County Courthouse in Bellefonte, Pa. in early September. Read moreAP Photo/Matt Rourke

The Justice Department Wednesday filed charges against Agostino Abbatiello, a former Penn State student accused of leading a sprawling cocaine trafficking operation that operated primarily out of two fraternity houses near campus.

Abbatiello, who is 24 and from Westbury, N.Y., was charged in a federal indictment with one count of conspiracy to distribute cocaine and six counts of distribution of cocaine.

Between January 2023 and December 2024, Abbatiello was “a major supplier” of cocaine on campus, federal prosecutors said, and recruited both fraternity brothers and pledges to help prepare and sell it. He sourced the drug from Philadelphia and New York, ultimately distributing over 5 kilograms, or more than 10 pounds, according to the federal indictment.

If convicted, the charges carry a mandatory minimum of 10 years in prison, the Justice Department said.

Abbatiello pleaded not guilty to the charges Wednesday. His lawyer, Philip Masorti, did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

Pennsylvania Attorney General Dave Sunday had previously said Abbatiello and other leaders in the fraternities drafted new pledges to package and sell cocaine as part of the pledge process. They described an organized, multiyear drug enterprise, with business so steady that when one brother stopped being able to sell because he went abroad or graduated, another took his place.

Abbatiello and 13 codefendants, all but one of whom were Penn State students around the time of the alleged operation, face related state charges. The Justice Department said the Pennsylvania AG’s office will assist with the federal prosecution.

Penn State also announced Wednesday that it would no longer recognize Delta Upsilon, one of the two main fraternities named in the indictment, for at least four years, cutting it off from university funding and university-sanctioned events such as THON.

The college said it had launched its own investigation of the fraternity after state prosecutors announced charges in August, and that the school had found “a pattern of hazing that included extensive control over daily activities, acts of servitude, sleep deprivation [and] physical punishment.” The other main fraternity named in the indictment, Sigma Chi, already operated as an unrecognized group.

» READ MORE: Penn State cocaine trafficking co-defendants testified against the alleged orchestrator

About one-fifth of Penn State students are affiliated with Greek life, according to a 2024 report. The university’s Greek system came under intense scrutiny in 2017, when Tim Piazza, a sophomore pledging Beta Theta Pi, fell down the stairs at a booze-filled fraternity hazing party, after drinking 18 drinks in 82 minutes. No one called for help for nearly 12 hours, and he later died.

Nearly a decade later, the cocaine trafficking allegations have raised new questions about the culture inside Penn State’s fraternities.

“It’s ingrained as a part of the new member process. So you’re socializing and setting expectations for all of your new members, and that culture replicates itself,” said Pietro Sasso, a faculty research fellow with the Penn State Timothy J. Piazza Center for Fraternity & Sorority Research, where he studies Greek life.

He pointed to a culture of hypermasculinity in fraternities, where research suggests drugs are often part of the pledging process.

Abbatiello is being held in Clinton County Prison pending a detention hearing on November 24.

Staff reporter Abraham Gutman contributed to this report.